58 photos

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Amenities photo

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photo

Book and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, 11965

Great

8.2

8.7

/10

3.9

3.5

“Sunset Beach offers fine views and a laid-back vibe!”view full review

3-star beachfront hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Accommodations

Sunset Beach offers 14 rooms with varying views of the beach and bay, giving guests a taste of coastal living. Each room is equipped with a refrigerator, microwave, and personal items storage, allowing for the comfort of home during a getaway. The hotel's layout encourages guests to immerse themselves in the surrounding nature and beach aesthetics.

Dining Options

Sunset Beach features on-site dining with its Beach Café, where breakfast is served with scenic seaside vistas. Guests can enjoy a selection of light refreshments and beverages while taking in the ocean's charm. The café provides a relaxed setting for casual meals throughout the day.

Amenities

The hotel provides direct beach access, allowing guests to engage in swimming, sunbathing, and other water activities at their convenience. Guests can also take advantage of outdoor seating and fire pits for gatherings during the evenings. Beach rentals are available on-site, simplifying access to activities such as kayaking and paddleboarding.

Location

Located in Shelter Island Heights, Sunset Beach provides easy access to local shops, tranquil walking paths, and nearby parks. It is conveniently situated near the ferry terminal, facilitating travel to and from the mainland. The surrounding area is rich in scenic views, promoting exploration and outdoor activities.

Family-Friendly Features

Sunset Beach accommodates families by offering rooms suitable for extra adults and children upon request. The beachfront location provides a spacious area for children to play and explore safely. Cribs and rollaway beds are available, ensuring comfort for families traveling with young children.

Highlights

Location: Shelter Island Heights, near local shops

Dining: Beach Café serving breakfast

Amenities: Direct beach access and fire pits

Family-Friendly: Cribs and rollaway beds available

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

July 2026 - July 2027

Sun

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

July 2026

August 2026

September 2026

October 2026

November 2026

December 2026

January 2027

February 2027

March 2027

April 2027

May 2027

June 2027

Choose dates to see prices

Check-in/ Check-out

Facilities

Experience a variety of amenities at the boutique hotel, crafted to ensure your comfort and unforgettable moments

Charming Restaurant Experience

“I had a good experience at the restaurant, which offers a blend of French-American cuisine. We enjoyed the ambiance and the fresh food, especially the warm artichoke and Basque cheese. Although we experienced a hiccup with our reservation, the hostess was very accommodating, ensuring we were taken care of.” read full review

Quirky Charm

“While the bathroom could use some updates, it adds to the overall character of the stay. The vintage design brought a certain nostalgic charm, though it did remind me of simpler accommodations. Just keep in mind that it leans to the rustic side-perfect for those who appreciate a more laid-back vibe!” read full review

Comfort with Character

“The room we stayed in had a unique mix of rustic decor with plain comforts that felt homey. Despite being basic, the view of the bay made waking up a pleasure. It's not the fanciest accommodation, but the character of the room added to our overall experience on the island.” read full review

Fun Evening Vibes

“The evening atmosphere was vibrant, especially with the DJ playing music as the sun set over the beach. It was lively and perfect for socializing. I loved the unique vibes of the place; it's definitely a great spot for some fun, albeit a bit more party-centric during the weekends!” read full review